Getting Elderly Parents to Stop Driving
When Senior's Should No Longer Drive
Generally, no individual plans for a
time when he or she will no longer be able to drive. In fact,
your loved one probably assumes that he or she will know when to
stop driving, and at the same time, he or she probably believes
that some of his or her friends aren't safe drivers.
Most individuals, however, never realize that it is time to stop driving. Instead, when faced with the lack of access to essential services, loss of social independence, reduced mobility, and isolation that come as a result of restricted or terminated driving privileges, an older adult often becomes defensive of his or her ability and right to drive. Even individuals who realize that driving may pose a threat to themselves and others struggle through the question of whether or not to give up the wheel.
Did you know that older drivers have higher rates of fatal crashes, based on miles driven than any other group except young drivers, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS)? The high death rate is due in large part to their frailty. Older people are less likely to survive an injury than younger people.
It isn't unusual for adult child caregivers to be faced with this dilemma:
Mom or dad is no longer safe to drive, for reasons that could include physical or mental deterioration. But they refuse to stop driving, and won't give up their car keys. This can be a tricky thing for an adult child to navigate-and losing driving privileges can be devastating for an elderly person.
It represents losing their independence, and that can be very hard to accept. However, when your parent's life is on the line-not to mention those of other people on the road-there may be no getting around it.
A frank conversation with your parent is the place to start. If you present it the right way, you may not face the problem of your parent refusing to let go of the keys.
Elderly parent refuses to give up the keys...
Bring Medical Documentation
It can be tempting to bring up the latest scary driving experience you had with the parent and how worried you are, but that could just make them more defensive. Instead, stick to the facts-your mom's failing vision, your dad's chemotherapy, or whatever mental or physical condition is impairing the parent's driving. Have the medical documentation handy.
Offer Alternatives
Losing the car keys means losing independence-and that can be scary for anyone. If you can present alternatives, it may help your parent accept the decision. Look into community ride-sharing organizations or transportation services for seniors, the public transportation routes to places where your parents often go, or have a plan in place for friends and family to provide rides. Make sure your parent knows they can still get out of the house and do the things they love.
Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), senior citizens must have access to basic transportation services. That means that any city providing public transportation in general must also offer paratransit or transportation services for people with disabilities. This service must be equivalent to the public transportation services available to the public at large in terms of days and hours of service, as well as response times. It could be worth it to look into the options available for the elderly in your area.
An average of 586 older adults are injured every day in crashes. Of course, you can prepare as well as possible, and the conversation still may not go as you hoped. You could just take the parent's keys anyway; however, this could damage your relationship with your parent, and it could also have legal consequences. There have been documented cases of the parent reporting their car stolen after an adult child took the keys away. If you want to avoid a messy situation, here are a few things to try next.
Ask your parent's doctor for help
If the doctor, optometrist, or ophthalmologist tells your parent they are no longer safe to drive, your parent may be more likely to listen. The doctor can also fill in a medical status report that can be given to the DMV in your state.
Talk to your DMV
You can go to your DMV directly and ask them to give your parent a new vision test, paper test, and even a driving test with an inspector. You may need the medical report from your doctor. The inspector can then determine whether your parent is still roadworthy. You don't have to wait until the parent's driver's license is up for renewal; you can make this request at any time. In some states, you can ask the DMV not to release the name of the person who requested the test.
Ask your attorney for help
There could be serious financial and legal consequences if your parent gets into an accident and injures someone else. You could ask the family lawyer about the dangers to your parents' estate and your inheritance should that happen. This might be more persuasive to your parents than your request alone.
It can be difficult to ask your parent to give up the car keys-and it can be a major blow to them to lose that independence. However, it may be necessary-both for your parent's safety and the safety of others on the road. Talk to your lawyer, doctor, or the DMV for help if you need to-and hopefully you can keep your parent and other drivers safe.
Medicare and Transportation
In some cases, Medicare may pay for limited, medically necessary, non-emergency ambulance transportation if you have a written order from your doctor stating that ambulance transportation is medically necessary. For example, you may need a medically necessary ambulance transport to a dialysis facility if you have End-Stage Renal Disease.
Or, you may be able to arrange for Non Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) if transportation is needed. Non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) includes transportation services offered to patients and healthcare consumers who face extraordinary barriers getting to their medical appointments.
Related Article:
Most individuals, however, never realize that it is time to stop driving. Instead, when faced with the lack of access to essential services, loss of social independence, reduced mobility, and isolation that come as a result of restricted or terminated driving privileges, an older adult often becomes defensive of his or her ability and right to drive. Even individuals who realize that driving may pose a threat to themselves and others struggle through the question of whether or not to give up the wheel.
Did you know that older drivers have higher rates of fatal crashes, based on miles driven than any other group except young drivers, according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS)? The high death rate is due in large part to their frailty. Older people are less likely to survive an injury than younger people.
It isn't unusual for adult child caregivers to be faced with this dilemma:
Mom or dad is no longer safe to drive, for reasons that could include physical or mental deterioration. But they refuse to stop driving, and won't give up their car keys. This can be a tricky thing for an adult child to navigate-and losing driving privileges can be devastating for an elderly person.
It represents losing their independence, and that can be very hard to accept. However, when your parent's life is on the line-not to mention those of other people on the road-there may be no getting around it.
A frank conversation with your parent is the place to start. If you present it the right way, you may not face the problem of your parent refusing to let go of the keys.
Elderly parent refuses to give up the keys...
Bring Medical Documentation
It can be tempting to bring up the latest scary driving experience you had with the parent and how worried you are, but that could just make them more defensive. Instead, stick to the facts-your mom's failing vision, your dad's chemotherapy, or whatever mental or physical condition is impairing the parent's driving. Have the medical documentation handy.
Offer AlternativesLosing the car keys means losing independence-and that can be scary for anyone. If you can present alternatives, it may help your parent accept the decision. Look into community ride-sharing organizations or transportation services for seniors, the public transportation routes to places where your parents often go, or have a plan in place for friends and family to provide rides. Make sure your parent knows they can still get out of the house and do the things they love.
Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), senior citizens must have access to basic transportation services. That means that any city providing public transportation in general must also offer paratransit or transportation services for people with disabilities. This service must be equivalent to the public transportation services available to the public at large in terms of days and hours of service, as well as response times. It could be worth it to look into the options available for the elderly in your area.
An average of 586 older adults are injured every day in crashes. Of course, you can prepare as well as possible, and the conversation still may not go as you hoped. You could just take the parent's keys anyway; however, this could damage your relationship with your parent, and it could also have legal consequences. There have been documented cases of the parent reporting their car stolen after an adult child took the keys away. If you want to avoid a messy situation, here are a few things to try next.
Ask your parent's doctor for help
If the doctor, optometrist, or ophthalmologist tells your parent they are no longer safe to drive, your parent may be more likely to listen. The doctor can also fill in a medical status report that can be given to the DMV in your state.
Talk to your DMV
You can go to your DMV directly and ask them to give your parent a new vision test, paper test, and even a driving test with an inspector. You may need the medical report from your doctor. The inspector can then determine whether your parent is still roadworthy. You don't have to wait until the parent's driver's license is up for renewal; you can make this request at any time. In some states, you can ask the DMV not to release the name of the person who requested the test.
Ask your attorney for help
There could be serious financial and legal consequences if your parent gets into an accident and injures someone else. You could ask the family lawyer about the dangers to your parents' estate and your inheritance should that happen. This might be more persuasive to your parents than your request alone.
It can be difficult to ask your parent to give up the car keys-and it can be a major blow to them to lose that independence. However, it may be necessary-both for your parent's safety and the safety of others on the road. Talk to your lawyer, doctor, or the DMV for help if you need to-and hopefully you can keep your parent and other drivers safe.
Medicare and Transportation
In some cases, Medicare may pay for limited, medically necessary, non-emergency ambulance transportation if you have a written order from your doctor stating that ambulance transportation is medically necessary. For example, you may need a medically necessary ambulance transport to a dialysis facility if you have End-Stage Renal Disease.
Or, you may be able to arrange for Non Emergency Medical Transportation (NEMT) if transportation is needed. Non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) includes transportation services offered to patients and healthcare consumers who face extraordinary barriers getting to their medical appointments.
Related Article:
Home | About | Articles | Resources | Site Map | Privacy Policy
Elder Options of Texas
Copyright 2001-2024
All Rights Reserved
DISCLAIMER: Links to other websites or references to products, services or publications do not imply the endorsement or approval of such websites, products, services or publications by Elder Options of Texas. The determination of the need for senior care services and the choice of a facility is an extremely important decision. Please make your own independent investigation.